On October 20, 2026, six large U.S. employers—Aramark, Kraft Heinz, Whirlpool, W.W. Grainger, Ralph Lauren, and Sterling Jewelers—sued UnitedHealth Group, one of the country’s largest claims administrators for company-funded, self-insured medical plans.
The landmark lawsuit, filed in a Texas U.S. District Court, contends that UnitedHealth, acting as a third-party administrator (TPA) for these companies’ self-funded medical plans, made improper claims payments, engaged in self-dealing, and restricted the companies’ rights to audit their own plan data.
The case is a major milestone for employers with self-funded health plans. For the first time, audit rights are going from a favorable contractual provision to the core fiduciary responsibility they are under the Employee Retirement Income Security Act (ERISA). This article explores the case details, what it means for plan sponsors, and practical steps to take now. A Q&A at the end addresses common questions.
Understanding the Lawsuit: Aramark/Kraft Heinz v. UnitedHealth Group
#1 Who’s Involved?
The plaintiffs—six household-name employers—began using UnitedHealthcare as their TPA starting in 2020. Their complaint alleges violations of ERISA fiduciary duties, prohibited transactions, contract breaches, negligence, and unjust enrichment.
#2 What Is Alleged in the Case?
- Claims Approval on Auto Pilot: United’s systems allegedly approved and paid claims with minimal human review, including claims with missing billing codes, duplicate charges, uncovered services, and pricing far above market rates. Many claims were approved within moments of submission.
- Lower Scrutiny for Self-Funded Plans: United is accused of applying less rigorous standards when the money at risk belongs to employer-sponsored self-funded plans (the plaintiffs), compared to United’s own fully insured plans.
- Self-Dealing: United allegedly paid higher rates to providers it owns or employs, and retained undisclosed “shared savings” fees on out-of-network claims—sometimes keeping more in fees than the provider received for the care itself.
- Cross-Plan Offsetting: The plaintiffs allege United used overpayments from one plan to cover underpayments for others, including its own fully insured business, without crediting the original plan—potentially harming plan assets.
- Obstructing Audit Rights: Perhaps most importantly, United is accused of withholding, corrupting, or restricting access to claims data, making it impossible for employers to audit payments and fees. Several plaintiffs claim they received no usable claims data.
#3 What Relief Are the Plaintiffs Seeking?
The six companies are asking the court for an injunction requiring United to provide complete claims data— including the EDI 835 remittance files.
Generally, claims details are provided on an audit claims file for audit purposes. These TPA electronic claims files are an internal data export — powerful and detailed, and a good audit firm specifies what needs to be included but the files are still built to the TPA’s own specs. As such it can be regenerated, filtered, or formatted differently each time it is pulled.
An EDI 835 is a standardized, federally regulated remittance file that tells a provider exactly what was paid and why. The 835 is more structured and auditable; the electronic claims file is more comprehensive but variable.
Comparing the 835 electronic remittance advice files that detail exactly what was billed and what was paid, against the claims file is another layer of verification to identify if there are differences. Discrepancies between the two — for example, a claim that appears paid in the electronic claims file but shows a different net amount in the 835 — can be a strong indicator of a pricing or adjudication error or irregularity.
Why Complete Audit Rights to Meet Fiduciary Duty Matter

- Plan Sponsors’ Non-Delegable Duty to Monitor: Under ERISA, employers that sponsor health plans are fiduciaries. This means they have a non-delegable duty to select and monitor service providers—including TPAs. If a TPA restricts access to claims data, the sponsor cannot verify whether plan assets are being used appropriately, which exposes them to legal and financial risk.
- Why Sample Audits Fall Short: The complaint points out (and many industry experts agree) that reviewing a sample of a few hundred claims is statistically incapable of surfacing systemic issues—like high-dollar errors, duplicate payments, or excluded services. Only a full-population, claim-level review using complete data can reliably detect these patterns.
- Claims Data Belongs to the Plan: The funds that pay claims come from the plan—that is, from the sponsoring employer and its employees. Therefore, claims data is the plan’s property, and the TPA’s obligation to provide data is not a courtesy; it’s a basic requirement for fiduciary oversight. Allegations that a TPA can withhold or degrade these files, while being paid to adjudicate claims are completely contrary to independent audit practices.
What Plan Sponsors Should Do Today, Soon, and Long-Term
#1 Immediate Steps to Take:
- Check Your TPA Contract: Locate your audit clause. What data are you entitled to? In what format? On what timeline? Can you use an independent auditor?
- Request Your Claims Data: Work with an experienced, reputable audit firm and formally request your complete claims file. In case of problems or suspected discrepancies you can additionally request the 835 remittance files for current and prior years and conduct a comparison. Also, document how your TPA responds—do you get the data, and is it complete and usable?
- Inventory Your Data Access: Can you reconstruct what was billed, what was paid, and why? If not, your plan faces the same risk as the plaintiffs.
#2 Next Steps:
- Renegotiate Audit Rights to Include: Explicit rights to complete electronic claims file and EDI files (835/837 files) on an ongoing basis; the right to use a third-party auditor without TPA consent; a clear understanding and agreement on audit scope, data formats, and frequency — including remedies if data is late or in unclear formats; and, transparency on shared savings, out-of-network arrangements, and cross-plan offsets.
- Continuously Monitor Payments: Move away from sample audits in favor of ongoing monitoring that reviews 100 percent of claims to catch mistakes, overpayments, and any other irregularities.
- Preserve Documents: Keep records—minutes, data requests, audit findings—to demonstrate fiduciary diligence if ever challenged.
#3 Plan and Implement for the Future:
- Audit TPA Performance as Oversight: Compare independent audit and monitoring reports against your TPA’s self-reporting — don’t rely solely on your TPA’s reports.
- Watch for Conflicts of Interest: Double-check your TPA’s relationships with providers or fee arrangements and include contractual protections or require disclosures.
Work with an Independent Claim Auditor

Independent audit firms are essential partners for plan sponsors navigating these new risks. For example, TFG Partners specializes in:
- Performing independent claims audits using complete data sets.
- Implementing continuous claims monitoring for near real-time detection of improper payments.
- Reviewing and strengthening TPA agreements.
- Supporting PBM (pharmacy benefit manager) RFP evaluations through detailed, fact-based financial reviews to ensure transparent, competitive pharmacy contracts.
As the legal landscape continues to evolve, working with an independent auditor with no conflicts of interest is more important than ever.
The UnitedHealth TPA litigation is an important opportunity for self-funded medical plan management. We have advised for years that audit rights are essential—and are a fiduciary imperative.
Plan sponsors should act now to secure data access, implement robust audits, and proactively manage risk in their health plans.
Important Legal Disclaimer
This article is only intended for informational and background purposes. It should not be considered legal advice. Each plan’s ERISA counsel should advise on contracts and obligations. The claims in the UnitedHealth lawsuit are unproven; UnitedHealth Group has publicly stated it will defend itself against the allegations in Federal Court.
Questions and Answers About this Topic
Q: How do the lawsuit’s claims relate to fiduciary responsibilities?
A: Employers’ self-funded health plans must have audit rights to monitor their claims administrators (TPAs) under ERISA. A part of the lawsuit is about access to complete claims data, which is required to verify that plan funds are used appropriately. Plans must conduct oversight to avoid legal and financial risk.
Q: Why are 835 files a point in the lawsuit?
A: When auditors review a health plan’s claims, they need to see comprehensive TPA claims files and in case of a suspected exception might include access to 835 remittance advice files to review what was billed, what was paid, and any adjustments. Independent review of 835 files is foundational to ultimate validation in claims auditing.
Q: Why isn’t a sample audit good enough?
A: People with experience in the claims audit industry know that sample audits of a few hundred claims won’t reliably find systemic problems. Only full-population, claim-level data analysis can detect large-scale errors or patterns of abuse.
Q: What happens if my company requests full claims data and our TPA declines?
A: Keep clear records of your requests and their responses. If necessary, bring in your ERISA counsel to enforce any contract rights. When your company renews its contract, you can add stronger language or switch to a new TPA with better data access.
Q: What happens if my company does nothing?
A: Some company-sponsored health plans have already been hit with fiduciary breach lawsuits, so you must meet your ERISA fiduciary obligations. Doing so requires audit rights and data access, so they are essential for legal and financial reasons.
Q: Why are independent auditors important?
A: Independent auditors help ensure your plan meets fiduciary and legal requirements and manage costs with claims reviews and continuous monitoring. They can also help ensure your TPA agreement provides the audit rights and data access you need.

