Why Audit Benefit Plan Claims?
When looking for ways to serve members well and control costs, benefit plan sponsors may overlook the value of claims auditing. For some, the thought of an audit’s price may be front of mind. But experience shows that claim reviews add to the bottom line, not subtract from it, and can be charged as plan expenses.
A TFG audit commonly finds recoverable errors that are four or more times the project cost.
Why audit medical, pharmacy, and other benefit claims? It’s common to assume that your third-party administrator (TPA) or pharmacy benefit manager (PBM) pays claims with reasonable accuracy. Many guarantee their performance and promise low single-digit error rates.
However, you, as a plan sponsor, have the fiduciary responsibility to ensure that the accuracy is delivered. This is a critical issue in today’s world, where both governmental agencies and plan members alike increasingly hold the plan sponsor accountable for prudently managing the plan’s resources.
And no matter how accurate your administrators are, there are always cases of missed discounts or rebates, wrong or duplicate billing, errors in member eligibility, problems with plan setup, etc. Periodic claim auditing is the best way to conduct needed oversight.
What Do Claim Audits Check and Report?
Benefit plan claim audits check and report on every key area your claim administrator handles. When 100 percent of claims are reviewed, and the findings reported clearly, you have an instant independent analysis of how your plan is working. We at TFG Partners have a library of hundreds of error detection algorithms, and here are some of the most common issues we audit for you:
Even though they include several phases, our pharmacy and medical claim audits move quickly and require very little of your time. Once the initial setup is completed, we review 100 percent of your claims electronically. The software tests all claims against your plan setup, medical and correction adjudication requirements, other payer coordination, and eligibility data and includes all adjustments and reversals. Our process is a vast improvement compared to earlier random-sample methods.
Next, we add human oversight to examine the error patterns discovered in the electronic review closely. Individual claims are flagged for scrutiny when they demonstrate an irregularity. Also, our error tests are customized to your plan and differ for medical, pharmacy, and other benefit claims.
Fiduciary Best Practices: A New Urgency
A new urgency in following “fiduciary best practices” is sweeping through the employer-funded health benefits industry. It’s sparked by highly publicized class-action lawsuits filed by activist law firms and, more recently, a landmark suit of members suing the plan sponsor for derogation of those fiduciary responsibilities. In summary, a growing list of employers sponsoring plans, as well as the managers of these plans, are being sued.
Medical claim auditing falls under fiduciary best practices and is an excellent way to gather plan performance data to make improvements and defend against lawsuits. Some plans go as far as monitoring their claims continuously with monthly reporting.
Fiduciary Best Practices: A New Urgency
A new urgency in following “fiduciary best practices” is sweeping through the employer-funded health benefits industry. It’s sparked by highly publicized class-action lawsuits filed by activist law firms. They are targeting a growing list of large employers sponsoring plans.
Medical claim auditing falls under fiduciary best practices and is an excellent way to gather plan performance data to make improvements and defend against lawsuits. Some plans go as far as monitoring their claims continuously with monthly reporting.
What Plans Does Claim Auditing Help?
TFG Partners claim review services are appropriate for all mid and large-size employer-funded plans. The more members you have enrolled and the more complex your benefits set up, the higher the probability of claim payment irregularities and errors.
An even more significant long-term opportunity lies in identifying setup errors that can be corrected to stop problems that multiply over time. It reduces costs and waste and means fewer incorrect payments that need to be recovered in the future.
Our work improves your plan performance to both help employees and reduce costs.
What we do helps more than bare-bones audits, reporting only data and doing little else.
Plan sponsors with accurate audit data in hand are much better positioned for revising and improving contracts with TPAs and PBM’s) Over time, these improvements significantly help control benefit plan costs.
What Process Steps are Included?
Step #1
Review Plan Provisions
Step #2
Audit and Analysis
Step #3
Advice
Step #4
Recovery
Our Claim Audits Produce a Healthy ROI
The return on investment (ROI) for our benefit claim audits is impressive. The returns routinely go as high as four or more times the price of the service. And once problems get fixed, ongoing overpayments disappear. It’s rare to contract for an outsourced service that adds to your bottom line, but we offer that opportunity.
When your auditor is your advocate, your plans perform how they are supposed to — employees are well served, and costs are managed. Since our founding, we’ve been dedicated to the ideals of caring for employees better while saving companies money.
To us, it has always made sense to add value as we work so that our services are revenue-positive. As a top medical auditing claims company, we provide the industry’s best ROI.
Our Claim Audits Produce a Healthy ROI
The return on investment (ROI) for our benefit claim audits is impressive. The returns routinely go as high as four times the price of the service. It’s rare to contract for an outsourced service that adds to your bottom line, but we offer that opportunity.
When your auditor is your advocate, your plans perform how they are supposed to — employees are well served, and costs are managed. Since our founding, we’ve been dedicated to the ideals of caring for employees better while saving companies money.
To us, it has always made sense to add value as we work so that our services are revenue-positive. As a top medical auditing claims company, we provide the industry’s best ROI.
How Often Should Plans Audit?
We recommend auditing claims at least every other year and annually for larger clients because there are significant cost savings and member service improvement opportunities to be identified. Ideally, you’ll follow up by adding our continuous monitoring service. It provides monthly reporting for oversight to keep your plan well-managed and increasingly, TPA’s and PBM’s are providing allowances for audit services that assure the clients’ plans are monitored and perform well.
Our data security is tightly controlled and with continuous monitoring service, you can view your reports securely online through our web portal.
If you’re about to begin working with a new TPA or PBM, an implementation audit after the first 90 days is crucial. It’s the best way to verify your plan has been set up correctly in the vendor’s system and that you are receiving all the contracted benefits. If not, you can have them make corrections immediately.
Frequently Asked Questions
Why should our company audit its benefit plan claims if our administrator already guarantees accuracy?
A guarantee is a promise, not proof. As the plan sponsor, verifying that promise is actually your job under ERISA — and even TPAs or PBM’s with strong accuracy guarantees still produce missed discounts, rebates, duplicate billing, and other adjudication and eligibility mistakes in practice. An auditing medical claims is how you find out what’s actually happening instead of what’s been promised.
What does a medical claims audit actually check and report on?
Hundreds of obvious and not so obvious things, tested against every claims. Medical audits cover The review covers, among others:
- Other Party Liability — other carriers, Medicare, HDHP member liability;
Technical / Medical correct coding – Technical correct coding includes e.g duplicates, global fee adherence, assistant surgeon discounting while Medical correct coding — multi-bilateral procedures without modifier, exceeded treatment limits; - Plan adherence — all your plan’s unique benefits, from copays and visit limits to non-covered services (e.g., nutraceuticals, biofeedback, non-authorized acupuncture).
PBM audits also look at the benefit adherence but further validate all financial contractual guarantees from discounts and rebates to pass through terms and exclusions. TFG Partners’ medical claims audit services run this against 100 percent of claims, then have a person look closely at anything the software flags.
How often should we audit our benefit plans, and who usually decides that schedule?
Every other year is the general rule, moving to annual for larger plans where more is at stake. It’s increasingly something benefits and finance leadership put on a standing governance calendar — the same way a financial audit gets scheduled — rather than treating it as a one-off project that happens whenever someone gets around to it. If you’re switching to a new TPA or PBM, it’s also worth running a smaller implementation audit around the 90-day mark to catch setup errors early. In addition, for clients that demand an prioritize full disclosure and financial prudence, our Continuous Monitoring services offer near real-time payment integrity, so issues can get resolved during and not long after the close of a plan year, saving some of our larger clients millions of dollars.
What’s the typical return on investment for a benefits claims audit?
Virtually all of our audits will recover at least the cost of the audit in refunds. However, actual ROI is a function of recovery and cost avoidance in the future and we see ROI’s from four times the audit’s cost in recoverable errors to 10 times and more. Given that the audit itself can usually be treated as a plan expense, audits should add to the bottom line rather than come out of the HR’s department’s budget. The bigger win is usually what happens after — once an error’s fixed, the overpayments it was causing generally stop too.
What if the audit doesn’t turn up any major problems — is it still worth doing?
Yes, and this comes up more than you’d think. A clean or mostly clean result isn’t a wasted engagement — it’s the documented, independent confirmation your leadership actually wanted in the first place. Instead of assuming your administrator is handling things correctly, you now have evidence of it, which is exactly what a benefits committee or board wants on record whether the news is good or the audit uncovers money.
What are "fiduciary best practices," and how does claims auditing fit in?
It’s really just shorthand for being able to show you actively oversaw your plan rather than designing it and walking away — and that kind of documentation has become a lot more relevant given the wave of class-action suits accusing plan sponsors of failing exactly that duty. A regular audit history is both a way to improve the plan and evidence you can point to if you ever need to defend it.
What does the medical claims audit process actually involve?
Four stages, roughly: reviewing your plan documents to settle any ambiguity about what’s actually covered and programming all correct benefits into TFG’s proprietary system, a full electronic review of the claims paid during the period, human follow-up on anything the software flags, and then advice and recovery once errors are confirmed. Running that against 100 percent of claims, not a sample, is what lets us point to individual errors instead of just an estimated error rate. And once the audit report is complete, TFG auditors, not clerical staff stay with the project for at least 180 days to ensure all promised fixes are implemented and approved recoveries and refunds are delivered. As proof of how seriously we take this value creating steps, we estimate that our teams can spend at least an additional 20-30 percent of the original project hours on this essential follow-up task.
Do claims audits check whether we’re actually getting our negotiated network rates, not just whether the benefit was covered?
Yes, and it’s an easy thing to overlook. Checking actual charges against contracted or reasonable-and-customary pricing is part of all health network accuracy audits, because network-pricing errors — a claim technically covered correctly but priced wrong — are a quiet, recurring source of overpayments that a benefit-only review won’t catch.
Does auditing our benefit plan work differently depending on which state we’re based in?
The fiduciary duty to oversee your TPA or PBM comes from federal ERISA rules, and it applies the same way regardless of which state your plan is based in. TFG Partners happens to be headquartered in Pittsburgh, but the audit itself doesn’t change based on geography. What matters is whether your administrator is being independently checked at all, and in cases of unique state requirements such as states with unique hospital billing rules or outlawed PBM spread pricing practices, we review those claims accordingly.
Does benefit claims auditing cover COBRA and other ancillary benefits, or just medical and Rx?
It extends further than most people expect. COBRA, dental, vision, worker’s comp, HSA/HRA, and eligibility verification all carry the same fiduciary logic as medical and Rx. Most clients bundle these into their core audit rather than running them separately, mainly because it’s more efficient to set up once and review everything together. For those clients with stop-loss, we even offer a separate stop-loss audit of the stop-loss carrier that helps you ensure that all claims covered under stop-loss are adjudicated and reimbursed correctly.




